New York A March
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | |
| Mike Cohen | Dan Mullarkey | Joe Sheehan | Tony Tucker | Paul Brownlee | Fenlon/Johnson | Dave Bengert | Brian Smith | Joe Glus | John Christie | |
| 8-12 | 12-10 | 10-12 | 11-11 | 21-13 Won | 14-11 | 16-16 | 16-11 | 6-14 | 10-12 | |
| 1 | Jones,C | Pujols,A | Mauer,J | Sizemore,G | HARDEN,R | Pedroia,D | HALLADAY,R | Ludwick,R | Teixeira,M | RIVERA,MARI | 1 |
| 2 | Drew,J | Ramirez,Han | Markakis,N | Youkilis,K | LINCECUM,T | Span,D | Utley,C | Rodriguez,A | Rollins,J | Napoli,M | 2 |
| 3 | SORIA,J | Mccann,B | BALFOUR,G | Hamilton,J | DEMPSTER,R | NATHAN,J | Ramirez,Man | Holliday,M | Roberts,B | Wright,D | 3 |
| 4 | Shoppach,K | Huff,A | KUO,H | Doumit,R | DEVINE,J | PEAVY,J | DUCHSCHERER | Hudson,O | Upton,B | LEE,CLIFF | 4 |
| 5 | Beltran,C | Kinsler,I | Gonzalez,Ad | Choo,S | PAPELBON,J | H0S20 | THORNTON,M | FUENTES,B | BROXTON,J | Berkman,L | 5 |
| 6 | Reyes,Jose | BUCHHOLZ,T | Iwamura,A | OSWALT,R | LOWE,D | SABATHIA,C | Martin,R | Bay,J | CHAMBERLAIN | Bradley,M | 6 |
| 7 | Pena,C | Giles,B | Mclouth,N | Longoria,E | ARREDONDO,J | Dejesus,D | Victorino,S | WADE,C | SANTANA,E | Hardy,J | 7 |
| 8 | WOOD,K | CARLSON,J | Quentin,C | GEARY,G | SAITO,T | Jeter,D | CAPPS,M | Ethier,A | SHIELDS,J | Gerut,J | 8 |
| 9 | JENKS,B | QUALLS,C | BRESLOW,C | ZAMBRANO,C | DOWNS,S | WAGNER,B | Suzuki,I | Iannetta,C | Soto,G | WEBB,B | 9 |
| 10 | BILLINGSLEY | Dukes,E | SHELL,S | JOHNSON,JIM | GrandersonC | Molina,Y | MARMOL,C | SHEETS,B | Ramirez,Ara | OHMAN,W | 10 |
| 11 | Ankiel,R | GREGG,K | Davis,C | OKAJIMA,H | Molina,B | NOLASCO,R | HUDSON,T | NELSON,J | PEREZ,R | Cameron,M | 11 |
| 12 | Uggla,D | Dunn,A | WAINWRIGHTA | Ross,C | Drew,S | Kemp,M | Hunter,T | HOWELL,J | EMBREE,A | SANTANA,JOH | 12 |
| 13 | COOK,A | Belliard,R | Wilson,Jack | HAMELS,C | Nady,X | WHEELER,D | Lee,D | Morneau,J | BURNETT,A | HAREN,D | 13 |
| 14 | Werth,J | ADAMS,M | HERNANDEZ,F | MARCUM,S | Dye,J | Jackson,C | Fielder,P | NUNEZ,L | Cust,J | Derosa,M | 14 |
| 15 | HAWKINS,L | RAMIREZ,R | Mora,M | Phillips,B | Glaus,T | Navarro,D | Theriot,R | RODRIGUEZ,F | BAKER,S | Blanco,G | 15 |
| 16 | KURODA,H | Johnson,Ree | Winn,R | DELCARMEN,M | Vazquez,R | Keppinger,J | Beltre,A | Escobar,Y | Guerrero,V | Cabrera,A | 16 |
| 17 | VOLQUEZ,E | CHI AL | LIDGE,B | MARTE,D | Damon,J | Abreu,B | BECKETT,J | GUTHRIE,J | Schumaker,S | Snyder,C | 17 |
| 18 | Atkins,G | Punto,N | Martinez,V | Young,M | Ramirez,Ale | Soriano,A | SHOUSE,B | Aviles,M | Ordonez,M | Cabrera,Mig | 18 |
| 19 | OLIVER,D | Tatis,F | Barmes,C | Guzman,C | Gordon,A | Inglett,J | SPRINGER,R | Wells,V | Ellsbury,J | GALARRAGA,A | 19 |
| 20 | Izturis,M | Lee,Carlos | PITTSBURGH | Johnson,K | Hawpe,B | RAMIREZ,E | Olivo,M | GARZA,M | VALVERDE,J | RYAN,BJ | 20 |
| 21 | Polanco,P | Rowand,A | Thames,M | Wigginton,T | Sanchez,F | GREINKE,Z | TulowitzkiT | GIESE,D | Scutaro,M | Byrd,M | 21 |
| 22 | SHERRILL,G | MATSUZAKA,D | CAIN,M | PierzynskiA | Delgado,C | Rolen,S | Guillen,C | VERLANDER,J | Laird,G | ALBERS,M | 22 |
| 23 | CINCINNATTI | LESTER,J | ZIEGLER,B | TORRES,S | Schneider,B | Overbay,L | LINEBRINK,S | Suzuki,K | MORROW,B | Carroll,J | 23 |
| 24 | Braun,RyanJ | MECHE,G | Harris,W | Laroche,Ada | Votto,J | WRIGHT,W | Varitek,J | Mientkiewic | STLOUIS | Burrell,P | 24 |
| 25 | Flores,J | DANKS,J | LITSCH,J | CORCORAN,R | FRANCISCO,F | BROCAIL,D | Grudzielane | Easley,D | SHIELDS,S | ROMERO,J | 25 |
| 26 | Giambi,Jaso | Inge,B | Ortiz,D | LOS ANGELES | CHI NL | CAMPILLO,J | MINNESOTA | BALTIMORE | Howard,R | PHILADELPHI | 26 |